Should You Mix Protein Shakes With Milk Or Water? Watch this great video.

As Amazon affiliates we may earn a commission if you purchase a product at no cost to you.

In the world of muscle building, the protein shake stands out as a convenient and quick meal on the run. Coach Lee Hayward, a prominent figure in bodybuilding nutrition, sheds light on a common dilemma faced by many enthusiasts is clear whey better with water or milk? We'll explore the factors influencing this decision and unravel the nutritional tale behind each choice.

Water vs. Milk: Coach Lee's Take

Coach Lee Hayward personally opts for water when mixing his protein shakes. The simplicity, convenience, and cost-effectiveness of water make it his preferred choice. He emphasizes that regardless of whether you choose water or milk, the shake will still serve its purpose - aiding in muscle building and recovery. The primary distinction lies in the nutritional value contributed by the chosen liquid.

Clear Whey with Water: The Simplicity Advantage

When it comes to mixing clear whey with water, Coach Lee sees it as the uncomplicated route. Water serves as a neutral and calorie-free base, allowing the protein powder to shine without additional flavors or nutritional complexities. The simplicity of water aligns seamlessly with those seeking a straightforward and quick solution for their protein intake. For Coach Lee, this minimalist approach not only streamlines the preparation process but also ensures a clean and unaltered taste of the clear whey.

Milk's Nutritional Impact on Clear Whey: Unraveling the Nutritional Tale

Turning attention to milk, Coach Lee acknowledges the potential impact on the nutritional profile of the protein shake. While the efficacy of clear whey remains intact when mixed with milk, the nutritional values shift. Clear whey combined with milk introduces additional calories, fat, and carbohydrates to the mix. Coach Lee underscores the need to scrutinize these nutritional aspects, especially for those meticulously tracking their macros or adhering to specific dietary plans.

Calculating Macros for Clear Whey: A Practical Approach

In the context of the water vs. milk debate, Coach Lee emphasizes a pragmatic approach. For individuals aiming to integrate clear whey into their dietary regimen, understanding the nutritional values of both water and milk is crucial. Calculating macros involves factoring in the additional elements introduced by milk and adjusting overall dietary plans accordingly. This approach ensures that the protein shake aligns with individual macro goals, allowing users to make informed decisions that suit their specific nutritional needs.

Personal Preference Prevails: The Clear Whey Dilemma

Ultimately, the decision to mix clear whey with water or milk hinges on personal preference. Coach Lee reiterates that both options remain viable, and the choice should align with individual taste, lifestyle, and fitness goals. Whether one opts for the simplicity of water or the creaminess of milk, the goal is to relish the benefits of clear whey while staying mindful of the nutritional adjustments required.

A man making a nutritional milk shake.
A man making a nutritional milk shake.

The Milk Dilemma

Addressing the milk question, Coach Lee dives into the nutritional labels of both regular 1% milk and almond milk. Regular 1% milk provides 110 calories, 12 grams of fat, 12 grams of carbohydrates (sugar derived from lactose), and 9 grams of protein per cup. Contrary to popular belief, milk is not as protein-rich as one might think. Almond milk, an alternative for those with lactose intolerance, offers 2 grams of fat, 8 grams of sugar, and a mere 1 gram of protein. While almond milk may not be a protein powerhouse, it provides a tasty option for those seeking an alternative to traditional milk.

Nutritional Breakdown of Regular 1% Milk:

Regular 1% milk, a commonly chosen liquid for protein shakes, presents a nutritional profile that demands attention. With 110 calories per cup, it provides 12 grams of fat, 12 grams of carbohydrates (sugar derived from lactose), and 9 grams of protein. Coach Lee challenges the popular belief that milk is a protein-rich beverage, highlighting that the protein content is not as substantial as commonly assumed. This revelation prompts users to consider the overall nutritional impact when incorporating milk into their clear whey shakes.

Almond Milk as an Alternative:

For those with lactose intolerance or seeking a dairy-free option, almond milk emerges as a viable alternative for mixing with clear whey. Coach Lee explores the nutritional composition of almond milk, which offers 2 grams of fat, 8 grams of sugar, and only 1 gram of protein per cup. While almond milk may not match the protein content of regular milk, it introduces a distinct taste and serves as an appealing choice for those looking to diversify their clear whey experience.

Beyond Protein: The Full Picture of Milk's Impact:

Coach Lee's emphasis extends beyond protein content, urging users to consider the comprehensive nutritional impact of milk on their clear whey shakes. The additional calories, fat, and carbohydrates introduced by regular milk can influence the overall macronutrient profile of the protein drink. This prompts individuals to make an informed choice based on their dietary goals, emphasizing the need to factor in these nutritional components when deciding between water and milk as a mixing base for clear whey.

Almond Milk: A Tasty Alternative:

While almond milk may not be a protein powerhouse, Coach Lee acknowledges its appeal as a tasty alternative to traditional milk. The lower protein content might be a trade-off for those who value the unique flavor and seek a dairy-free option. Almond milk, therefore, becomes a palate-friendly choice that enhances the sensory experience of consuming clear whey.

Calculating Your Macros

Coach Lee suggests a practical approach to the water vs. milk debate - consider the nutritional information of the chosen liquid and factor it into your overall diet plan. By adding up the calories, protein, and carbohydrates from the milk, you can make an informed decision based on your specific dietary needs. The key is to ensure that your protein shake aligns with your macro goals and overall nutrition plan.

Consider the Nutritional Information:

In navigating the water vs. milk debate, Coach Lee encourages users to take a closer look at the nutritional information of their chosen liquid. Whether opting for the simplicity of water or the creamy addition of milk, understanding the specific components of each is crucial. Clear whey, a protein powerhouse on its own, can be complemented or altered by the nutritional profile of the liquid used as a mixer.

Adding Up the Calories, Protein, and Carbohydrates:

Coach Lee's practical approach involves a meticulous calculation of macros, specifically calories, protein, and carbohydrates, when considering the inclusion of milk in clear whey shakes. By breaking down the nutritional content of milk and factoring it into the overall composition of the protein drink, individuals can make informed decisions aligned with their dietary needs and fitness goals.

Making Informed Decisions: Aligning with Your Dietary Needs:

The key takeaway from Coach Lee's approach is the emphasis on making informed decisions based on your specific dietary needs. Clear whey enthusiasts are encouraged to align their choices with their macro goals and overall nutrition plan. This involves a thoughtful consideration of the impact of milk on the overall macronutrient distribution within the context of one's daily intake.

Ensuring Clear Whey Alignment with Macros:

Coach Lee underscores the importance of ensuring that your clear whey shake aligns with your macro goals. Whether your focus is on protein intake, managing caloric intake, or balancing macronutrients, the choice between water and milk as a mixer should complement your broader nutritional strategy. This approach empowers individuals to customize their clear whey experience, optimizing it to meet their unique dietary and fitness objectives.

A woman drinking a bottle of protein shake.
A woman drinking a bottle of protein shake.

Personal Preference Matters

Ultimately, the decision to mix your protein shake with water or milk boils down to personal preference. Coach Lee reiterates that if it fits your macros and aligns with your dietary goals, go ahead and choose the option that suits your taste and lifestyle. Whether it's the simplicity of water or the creamy taste of milk, the goal is to enjoy your protein shake while meeting your nutritional needs.

The Essence of Personal Preference:

In the realm of clear whey mixing, Coach Lee reinforces the idea that personal preference plays a pivotal role. The experience of consuming a protein shake is not solely about meeting nutritional requirements; it's also about savoring the journey. Whether you find joy in the simplicity of water or delight in the creamy texture of milk, the essence of personal preference adds a layer of enjoyment to the process.

If It Fits Your Macros: A Guiding Principle:

Coach Lee's guidance extends to a fundamental principle - if it fits your macros, it's a viable choice. In the pursuit of fitness goals and adherence to dietary plans, individuals are encouraged to choose the mixing option that aligns with their macronutrient targets. This principle empowers users to make a choice that not only satisfies taste preferences but also contributes to their broader nutritional objectives.

Tailoring Choices to Taste and Lifestyle:

The beauty of personal preference lies in its adaptability to taste and lifestyle. Whether you opt for the convenience of water or the added flavor complexity of milk, the goal is to tailor your clear whey mix to your unique preferences. This customization ensures that each protein shake is a reflection of your individual tastes, making the process more enjoyable and sustainable in the long run.

Enjoying Your Protein Shake Experience:

Coach Lee's ultimate message is clear - the goal is to enjoy your protein shake while meeting your nutritional needs. The decision between water and milk becomes a personalized choice, enhancing the overall experience of consuming clear whey. As individuals embark on their fitness journey, they are encouraged to find satisfaction not only in the nutritional benefits but also in the sensory delight of their chosen mixing liquid.

Recommended Article

Clear Whey Protein: The New Trend in Protein Supplements
Discover the benefits of clear whey protein – a transparent and refreshing protein supplement for your fitness goals. Learn more!”

Frequently Asked Questions FAQs

Can I mix clear whey with other liquids?

Absolutely! While water and milk are the MVPs, you can flex your mixology muscles and experiment with other liquids like almond milk, coconut water, or even fruit juice. Just be cautious with the sugar content!

Is it okay to use flavored water?

Sure thing! Flavored water can add a hint of excitement to your clear whey adventure. However, be wary of artificial sweeteners; too much of a good thing can sometimes be, well, too much.

Can I mix clear whey with milk and water?

Why not? Mixology is an art, not a science! Feel free to blend both water and milk for a unique fusion of textures and flavors. Your taste buds might just throw a protein party in celebration.


In the realm of protein shakes, the water vs. milk debate is subjective. Coach Lee Hayward emphasizes that there's no one-size-fits-all answer, and the choice ultimately comes down to personal preference. As you embark on your muscle-building journey, remember to factor in the nutritional values of your chosen liquid and align it with your overall diet plan.