Are you a Squishmallow collector on the hunt for the rarity and most hard-to-find plushies on the market? Look no further! These one-of-a-kind Squishmallows are sure to be the crown jewels of your collection.

But with so many different infrequent Squishmallows out there, it can be overwhelming to track them all down. Don't worry, we've got you covered with our ultimate guide to the top 10 rarest Squishmallows on the market.

Rarest Squishmallow Ever? Watch this amazing video.

We Independently Review Products

Our goal is to provide honest, comprehensive reviews of products and services. We have strict guidelines in place to ensure that our reviews are independent and unbiased.

How We Review Rarest Squishmallow Products

Our editors have carefully chosen the products on this page for your consideration. SmartchoiceList may receive commissions or other compensation for purchases made through this page, but this does not influence our unbiased product reviews. Enjoy finding your next favorite thing!

Our Top Pick:

Aurora Pompom 9" Penguin Plush

The Squishmallow line of plush toys is designed to blend comfort and fun perfectly. With its vast selection of colors, sizes, and designs, Squishmallows will surely bring smiles to kids and adults alike. Our top pick from the collection is the Aurora Pompom 9" Penguin Plush – a cute and cuddly companion.

Bring this lovable penguin home today and add warmth and joy to your life. This Squishmallow is sure to bring comfort and joy wherever it may go. GUND has created unique teddy bears and other soft toys for over 120 years. Their high-quality, huggable plush designs are a lasting source of comfort for all ages and make the perfect gift for any occasion.

Aurora Pompom 9" Penguin Plush

PomPom 9' Penguin Plush with Blue Hat From Aurora World

Check Price

Unicorn Dreamcatcher Squishmallow

Why We Love It:

The unicorn’s dreamcatcher design and vibrant colors make it an eye-catching and unique addition to any collection. The Squishmallow is made from ultra-soft materials that are perfect for cuddling up. At 8 inches tall, this Squishmallow is the perfect size for snuggling, playing, and adding to any collection.

What you Should Know:

Squishmallow is machine washable and easy to clean. Recommended for ages three and up, this unicorn Squishmallow will bring smiles wherever it goes. Unique and rare, this Unicorn Dreamcatcher Squishmallow will make a fantastic addition to any collection or special gift for that special someone in your life.

Unicorn Dreamcatcher Squishmallow

These plushies are warm cuddly fun and the right size for taking with you wherever you go

Check Price

Squishmallows 8" Nightmare Before Christmas

Why We Love it:

This Squishmallows 8" Nightmare Before Christmas Jack Skellington is an absolute must for any Halloween or Nightmare. Not only does it have a unique design, but it also glows in the dark. The plush toy is made from ultra-soft materials, perfect for cuddling up. It's the perfect size for playing, snuggling, and adding to any collection.

What you Should Know:

This Squishmallow is machine washable and easy to clean. Recommended for ages two and up, this Squishmallows 8" Nightmare Before Christmas Jack Skellington makes a great gift or addition to any plush toy collection.

Squishmallows 8" Nightmare Before Christmas Jack Skellington is sure to spark imagination, be a source of comfort, and bring smiles wherever it may go. Bring this unique and spooky plush toy home today and add some extra spookiness to your collection.

Squishmallows 8" Nightmare Before Christmas

These super soft, collectible plush toys make great cuddle companions! The squishy plush is perfect to bring on long car rides, airplanes or to sleepovers!

Check Price

Galactic Cat Squishmallow

Why We Love it:

Carlita the Caticorn is truly out of this world! This galactic cat Squishmallow features bright colors and a unique design, making it an eye-catching addition to any collection.

The squishy plush toy is super soft and perfect for cuddling up. It's the ideal size for playing, snuggling, and adding to any collection.

What you Should Know:

The Galactic Cat Squishmallow is machine washable and easy to clean. Recommended for ages three and up, this Squishmallow is a fantastic gift or addition to any plush toy collection.

Bring Carlita the Caticorn home today and add some extra magic to your collection. This Squishmallow is sure to bring comfort and joy wherever it may go.

Galactic Cat Squishmallow

The large squishy plush makes for the perfect cuddle companion!

Check Price

Mermaid Tail Squishmallow

Why We Love it:

This adorable Pusheen mermaid tail Squishmallow is perfect for any fan of the popular cat cartoon. It features a fun mermaid design, and its pastel colors and embroidered details make this plush toy stand out.

The ultra-soft squishy plush material makes it ideal for cuddling and playing. Its perfect size makes it great for bringing to sleepovers or car rides.

What You Should Know:

The Pusheen Mermaid Tail Squishmallow is machine washable and easy to clean. Recommended for ages one and up, this Squishmallow is a fantastic gift or addition to any plush toy collection. Bring this unique and mythical plush toy home today and add some extra magic to your collection. This Squishmallow is sure to bring comfort and joy wherever it may go.

Mermaid Tail Squishmallow

This cute plush brings the magical Pusheen mermaid to life, featuring an embroidered pastel tail and adorable starfish bow.

Check Price

Golden Retriever Squishmallow

Why We Love it:

This golden retriever Squishmallow is the perfect companion for any animal lover. This plush toy stands out because of its beautiful golden fur, big brown eyes, and embroidered details. The ultra-soft squishy plush material makes it ideal for cuddling and playing. Its perfect size makes it great for bringing to sleepovers or car rides.

This glittering golden retriever is a sparse and glamorous find. With its soft, cuddly body and sparkling fur, this dog Squishmallow is a must-have for any collector with a love for all things sparkly.

What You Should Know:

The Golden Retriever Squishmallow is machine washable and easy to clean. Recommended for all ages, this Squishmallow is a fantastic gift or addition to any plush toy collection. Bring this lovable pup home today and add warmth and joy to your life. This Squishmallow is sure to bring comfort and joy wherever it may go.

Golden Retriever Squishmallow

These plushies are warm cuddly fun and the right size for taking with you wherever you go

Check Price

Squishmallows Official Kellytoy Plush

Why We Love it:

This adorable sloth in a Squishmallows Official Kellytoy Plush is perfect for any space explorer. Its unique design features an embroidered astronaut and various cosmic details, making this plush toy stand out. This out-of-this-world sloth is a rare and unique find. With its soft, cuddly body and adorable spacesuit design, this Squishmallow is the perfect addition to any space-themed collection.

What You Should Know:

The Sloth in a Spacesuit Squishmallow is machine washable and easy to clean. Recommended for all ages, this Squishmallow is a fantastic gift or addition to any plush toy collection.

Bring this unique and interstellar plush toy home today and add extra magic to your collection.

Squishmallows Official Kellytoy Plush

Exclusive 8 inch Squishmallow Simon the Sloth

Check Price

Penguin with a Scarf Squishmallow

Why We Love It:

Penguin with a Scarf Squishmallow is the perfect companion for any winter lover. Its beautiful white and black fur, big brown eyes, and colorful scarf make this plush toy stand out.

The ultra-soft squishy plush material makes it ideal for cuddling and playing. Its perfect size makes it great for bringing to sleepovers or car rides.

What You Should Know:

The Penguin with a Scarf Squishmallow is machine washable and easy to clean. Recommended for all ages, this Squishmallow is a fantastic gift or addition to any plush toy collection.

Bring this lovable penguin home today and add warmth and joy to your life. This Squishmallow is sure to bring comfort and joy wherever it may go.

GUND has created unique teddy bears and other soft toys for over 120 years. Their high-quality, huggable plush designs are a lasting source of comfort for all ages and make the perfect gift for any occasion.

Penguin with a Scarf Squishmallow

PomPom 9' Penguin Plush with Blue Hat From Aurora World

Check Price

Giraffe with Sunglasses Squishmallow

Why We Love It:

Squishmallows are the perfect combination of cuddly, soft, and squishy. They’re a great way to express yourself and show your love for animals. Plus, they make great gifts! The Squishmallow Official Kellytoy is perfect for kids 36 months and up – perfect for children who want to hug and cuddle their new best friend!

The Squishmallow Official Kellytoy comes in various colors and styles, so there’s something for everyone. Plus, they’re easy to clean and maintain, making them the perfect addition to any home. So go ahead – get your squad on with Squishmallows! It

What You Should Know:

The Squishmallow Official Kellytoy is made of polyester, making it super soft and squishy. It comes in various colors and styles, so there’s something for everyone. Plus, it’s easy to clean and maintain – just spot clean with mild soap. And since it doesn’t require any assembly, it’s perfect for children 36 months and up. So get your squad on with Squishmallows – the perfect way to show your love for animals!

Giraffe with Sunglasses Squishmallow

8 Inch Squishy Soft Plush Toy Animals (Gary Giraffe)

Check Price

Squishmallows Official Kellytoy Plush

Why We Love It:

Squishmallows Official Kellytoy Plush is a brand of stuffed toys made of polyester material. These plush toys come in various animal, cartoon characters, and Squishmallows designs, making them great for imaginative play. This 12-inch figure makes an ideal gift for children ages 0-5, perfect for cuddling or using other soft toys. The Squishmallows Official Kellytoy is suwillg plenty of joy and comfort to any child!

What You Should Know:

It is recommended to spot clean only with a damp cloth. Avoid submerging in water, as doing so may damage the material and color of this toy figure. Batteries are not required for this toy figure. The Squishmallows Official Kellytoy Plush comes in one piece and includes no additional pieces or parts. This sophisticated owl is a rare and chic find. With its soft, cuddly body and top hat design, this Squishmallow is the perfect addition to any collection with a love for all things stylish.

Squishmallows Official Kellytoy Plush

12" EFUA The Owl - Ultrasoft Stuffed Animal Plush - 2021!

Check Price

T-Rex in a Tutu Squishmallow

Why We Love it:

T-Rex in a Tutu Squishmallow is an adorable dinosaur plush toy that will bring joy and laughter to any space. Its unique design features a pink T-Rex wearing a tutu and embroidered details, making this plush toy stand out.

The ultra-soft squishy plush material makes it ideal for cuddling and playing. Its perfect size makes it great for bringing to sleepovers or car rides.

What You Should Know:

The T-Rex in a Tutu Squishmallow is machine washable and easy to clean. Recommended for all ages, this Squishmallow is a fantastic gift or addition to any plush toy collection. Bring this lovable T-Rex home today and add extra fun and joy to your life. This Squishmallow is sure to be a hit with kids of all ages. GUND has created unique teddy bears and other soft toys for over 120 years. Their high-quality, huggable plush designs are a lasting

T-Rex in a Tutu Squishmallow

The cutest, pink T-Rex that will steal your heart. Sized at 6" long and 11" tall, this adorable Plushie makes the perfect cuddle buddy.

Check Price

Conclusion

No matter which infrequent Squishmallow you add to your collection, these one-of-a-kind plushies are sure to be the crown jewels. So why wait? Click the "Check Price" button now and add one of these rarest Squishmallows to your collection today.

Frequently Asked Questions FAQs.

Which Squishmallows are hardest to find?

There are a few different Squishmallows that are considered to be rare or hard-to-find. These include the limited edition holiday Squishmallows, like the Christmas or Easter ones, as well as the speciality Squishmallows, like the mermaid or unicorn ones. Some of the rarest and most sought-after Squishmallows are the Ty beanie babies, which are no longer in production.

What are the occasional Squishmallows right now?

There are a few rare Squishmallows that are hard to find on the market right now. One of the rarest is the 8-inch Samantha Sloth, who was only available at Kohl's stores in 2019. Another hard-to-find Squishmallow is the 6-inch Jumbo Peppy Puppy, who was a Target exclusive in 2020.

Why is it so hard to find Squishmallows?

Squishmallows are one of the most popular plushies on the market, but they can be hard to find. There are a few reasons for this.

One reason is that Squishmallows are often sold out quickly. They're so popular that they tend to fly off store shelves as soon as they're restocked. This can make it difficult to find them in stock, especially if you're looking for a specific character or style.

Another reason is that Squishmallows are often only available in limited quantities. This means that once a particular style or character is sold out, it may be gone for good. This can make it hard to find the perfect Squishmallow for you or your child.

What was the first ever Squishmallow?

The first ever Squishmallow was released in October of 2020 and was an octopus named Opal. She was quickly followed by a release of four more characters in November; a fox, a unicorn, a dragon, and a black cat. These five original Squishmallows were sold exclusively at Target stores in the United States. The next wave of Squishmallows, which included eight new characters, was released in December of 2020.

What is inside Squishmallow?

There are a lot of different Squishmallows on the market, but what exactly is inside them? Each Squishmallow is filled with super soft marshmallow-like stuffing, making them perfect for cuddling. They come in a variety of sizes, including extra large, and each one has a unique design.

Squishmallow Fun for Boys: The Best Plushies for Your Lovely Boys.
Looking for the perfect Squishmallow for your little guy? Check out our top 10 picks for Squishmallows that boys will love.
Squishmallow Craze: Coziest Plushies on Amazon
Looking for the perfect Squishmallow? Check out our ultimate guide to the top 10 Squishmallows on Amazon. From unicorns to tacos
Squishmallow Love for Adults: The Best Plushies for Grown-Up Snuggles
Looking for the perfect Squishmallow for grown-up snuggles? Check out our top 10 picks for Squishmallows that adults will love, from sassy cats to elegant elephants. These ultra-soft and cuddly plushies are the perfect companions for any evening in.